Dusty Chalk Posted July 20, 2008 Report Posted July 20, 2008 From another thread:or variant thereof then certainly covers it, as it is still the white cathode follower design. How about speaker amps, are there any speaker amps that follow this design? How about preamps? Is there a corresponding solid state design? Perhaps with MOSFETs?
guzziguy Posted July 20, 2008 Report Posted July 20, 2008 google is your friend however http://www.cavalliaudio.com/cj/docs/WCFOptimization.pdf Tube CAD Journal: Tube regulators part 2, July 1999 and page 3 right after it. IMPORTANT read page 3 lots more about wcf at the tubecad site. And should another manufacturer make such a headphone amplifier, then you absolutely should listen to it. Why no one does may have to do with some of the conclusions of john broksie at the tubecad site. The capacitors thing is stupid to the extreme. If you were driving argon gas lasers which is what those juice cans are really designed for, then great. But for a headphone amplifier whose output power is 1 watt or less, those things are TEN THOUSAND times overkill. Capable of 25 amperes peak each. You show me a headphone that can take 25 amperes. As far as speaker amps, this circuit just does not apply. Now as to preamps, i do recall that someone did a preamp with a WCF as the output stage. I'll answer the other questions in the other thread in an hour or 2. Added KG's post about this in the "Colorado" thread because its information is valuable here.
kevin gilmore Posted July 20, 2008 Report Posted July 20, 2008 Can you use a mosfet as a WCF. The answer is clearly yes. But why would you want to? The output impedance of a tube is very high, and WCF is a trick to lower the output impedance. The output impedance of a mosfet is very low, and no tricks are necessary. Now if you want to know what the closest thing is to a WCF as solid state, the answer to that is simple. Nelson Pass. Whose power amp designs really can be considered an upside down WCF. Both are single ended designs with an active current source. A standard WCF has no voltage gain, an inverted WCF has significant voltage gain.
Dusty Chalk Posted July 20, 2008 Author Report Posted July 20, 2008 Can you use a mosfet as a WCF. The answer is clearly yes. But why would you want to? (shrugs) I don't know -- because asking stupid questions sometimes surprises me with good answers.Now if you want to know what the closest thing is to a WCF as solid state, the answer to that is simple. Nelson Pass. Whose power amp designs really can be considered an upside down WCF.That makes perfect sense, I love what I've heard of Nelson Pass designed amps. Thanks for the info. Will read that tubecad.com stuff offline.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now