Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Yep the end of analog!

Most people aren't paying attention that from now on, all audio, not just the

surround sound stuff is going to be digital delivered over hdmi. Things are going

to change and there is going to be lots of new product. With lots of bugs.

  • Replies 69
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
Yep the end of analog!

Most people aren't paying attention that from now on, all audio, not just the

surround sound stuff is going to be digital delivered over hdmi. Things are going

to change and there is going to be lots of new product. With lots of bugs.

DigitalFET.

Posted

Well it makes sense right??

isolated ultra speed digital delivered to the amplification device. true analog step

attenuator after the dac controlled by the CEC channel.

No ground loops ever. No more stupidass discussion of expensive interconnects...

Of course we will still have power cords to argue about, but i see that finally

taking a back seat to everything else.

Posted
Well it makes sense right??

isolated ultra speed digital delivered to the amplification device. true analog step

attenuator after the dac controlled by the CEC channel.

No ground loops ever. No more stupidass discussion of expensive interconnects...

Of course we will still have power cords to argue about, but i see that finally

taking a back seat to everything else.

I guarantee Virtual Dynamics will make a garden hose HDMI cable.

Posted
Yep the end of analog!

Most people aren't paying attention that from now on, all audio, not just the

surround sound stuff is going to be digital delivered over hdmi. Things are going

to change and there is going to be lots of new product. With lots of bugs.

What about "records"?
Well it makes sense right??

isolated ultra speed digital delivered to the amplification device. true analog step

attenuator after the dac controlled by the CEC channel.

No ground loops ever. No more stupidass discussion of expensive interconnects...

Of course we will still have power cords to argue about, but i see that finally

taking a back seat to everything else.

I find your ideas intriguing and would like to subscribe to your newsletter.

But alas, it will not be.

Power will always be analog. Speakers will always be analog. Music, itself, will always be analog, even if it's an analogue of analog.

Posted
I guarantee Virtual Dynamics will make a garden hose HDMI cable.

they won't be able to make a cable that meets the specifications. but they could still take a cheap HDMI cable and put a garden hose on top of it

Posted
What about "records"?

You have seen the USB turntables right??? Some of them are quite expensive.

A/D conversion, then RIAA in the digital domain...

Power will always be analog.

Ummmm... those ICEpower amps sure sound pretty nice for the average J6P

and even for some of the non-average types.

Speakers will always be analog

what about those new ionovac things that run on a 50khz square wave...

hdmi connectors won't fit thru a standard garden hose... Also won't fit thru

a standard conduit either, which is why i'm using hdmi to dual ethernet converters.

Posted
No, I meant power, as in AC from the wall.

And yes, I know you're playing devil's advocate, I'm not falling for it.

You will fall for it sooner or later.

Who is to say that AC power from the wall is analog.

Many of the el-cheapo UPS's available don't put out anything even

close to a sine wave. Much more like a stepped square wave.

And the new series of really expensive stuff (like the emerson/liebert units)

actually use some very high frequency as a pwm wave to make the output

look like 60 hz sine waves. And in doing so, they reduce the size and weight

almost a factor of 3. A unit i just installed today weighs less than 100 lbs

and puts out 6kw. Virtually all of the newest units in the 20kw to 100kw range

now do this as compared to the older ferrups units that make sinewaves with

a very large transformer.

Sooner or later if you put solar panels on your house, you would be very interested

in the much higher efficiency these things can do.

Posted
You will fall for it sooner or later.

Who is to say that AC power from the wall is analog.

According to quantum mechanics, analog is just a high resolution view of a world made up of only quantum states (a form of digital).

I think :confused:

Posted
Who is to say that AC power from the wall is analog.
I am.
Many of the el-cheapo UPS's available don't put out anything even

close to a sine wave. Much more like a stepped square wave.

And that's digital...how? A square wave is just as analog as a sine wave.

I mean, define your terms. What is "digital"? It's not just pulse width modulation, or PCM or DSD or even hysteresis loops (analog tapes had to overcome hysteresis even when recording and playing back in analog), it's taking time-sliced samples of an analog signal and then representing them as numbers in a model. A true digital power source would be a zero value, followed by a half period-cycle of undefined value, followed by a zero-length timeslice of full-on, follwed by a half period-cycle of undefined value, followed by full off again (assuming two-stage values -- or perhaps it'd be "full on" followed by negative "full on"...whatever). Digital has no analogue in the real world, it's just a way for computers and other digitally-based storage media to convert continuous values into discrete numbers that are contiguous without being continuous.

So I repeat, don't give me these "what if" scenarios without defining your terms.

(And yes, I'm having just as much fun with this as you are.)

that can be argued. digitally made music piped into a brain via, say, magnetic induction, would be much closer to all digital than digital to analog, assuming that the quasi-digital model of neuron activity is correct.
(waves a shovel in Jacob's general direction)
Posted

I'll have to get back to you on that. You'll excuse me if I don't take wikipedia as a canonical reference for that kind of information, but the use of examples makes me think that there might be something to it (DNA is, indeed, intuitive).

But I think there's more to it than just "discontinuous units", but also how they're used. My power example is discontinuous units; but in KG's power example, the power needs to be there the entire time for it to work -- the "form of square wave" is a red herring.

Posted
and it doesn't really need to be zero, any way. you're being inconsistent, when you look at digital computer fab and architecture. in a computer, values under a certain amount count as zero, and values over a certain amount count as 1 (and values out of range are errors that need to be taken into account by software). even in the best designed, best made, theoretically perfect chips, it's never a perfect on/off count, due to quantum effects. take manufacturing error and material imperfections into account, and a computer that works in the way you are describing would, well, not work.
But that's just the analog model of a digital world. From the computer's perspective, it doesn't know 2.2V from 2.27 -- all it knows is "1".

It's the classic image of converting an analog signal to a digital one that I'm thinking of, the one where it assigns a number to a value at a certain point in time. You're not sympathizing with the computer, I don't think.

I mean, in digital transmission, ones and zeros are usually represented by transitions between two values, not even a constant state value. It's not how it's represented that is important, it's the fact that they are discretely-stepped, discretely-timed values that's important. It's entirely an abstract concept.

I mean, even when you digitize (and back), one always has to take into account the limitations of whatever digitization process (or back) was used, to accurately re-render the analog signal.

Posted

I used the entirely different "Pfff". Are you so megalomaniacal as to believe you own the patent to all words that start with "pf"? What are you going to do about Pfefferneusse, are you going to sue the entire country of Germany, as well as all American housewives of German descent? You're in for a world of hurt.

I declare "fair use".

Posted
I used the entirely different "Pfff". Are you so megalomaniacal as to believe you own the patent to all words that start with "pf"? What are you going to do about Pfefferneusse, are you going to sue the entire country of Germany, as well as all American housewives of German descent? You're in for a world of hurt.

I declare "fair use".

pfair use even....

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.