Need suggestion for best slim optical disk drive

[sbelyo]

I need to purchase a slim SATA ODD for a slim HTPC case. I'll need DVD, CD, and Blu-Ray read support (best accuracy is what I'm looking for).  Write support is not as important but CDR, DVDR would be needed at least.  I'm really looking for the best slim ODD to finish ripping my CD, DVD, Blu-Ray collection to storage.

 

Edited November 28, 2017 by sbelyo

[grawk]

external drive?

[sbelyo]

Internal, sorry forgot that part

This is the case

http://www.silverstonetek.com/product.php?pid=446&area=en

Here's the dimensions of one that fits

128 x 129 x 12.7 mm ( W x D x H ) 
5.04" x 5.08" x 0.5" ( W x D x H ) 

Edited November 28, 2017 by sbelyo

[grawk]

yes, but why constrain yourself with a slower less reliable drive you won't need forever by insisting on a laptop drive for heavy usage?

 

[sbelyo]

true, I guess I was trying to un clutter my rack.  I'm not opposed to a full size drive, what's the best out there these days?

[purk]

An external desktop drive is a great solution though.  The rip speed is a lot faster and the drive is more solidly built.  I bought the LG Blu-ray writer recently and I'm super happy by the result.  

[sbelyo]

That seems to be what's widely available.  I was hoping for an internal sweet spot so I could ditch the external part.  I forgot that internal slim drives are not very reliable.  I haven't relied on disk based media in the workplace for years

this was the most accurate as of 2016 

Lite-On DVD Burner Black SATA Model iHAS124-14

[Dusty Chalk]

Wouldn't mind knowing what you're ripping DVDs with, I have some DVDs I'd like to get the audio off of (Riina Shingo...er...Ringo Sheena, some live concert DVDs, the Advanced Electronics series, etc.).

Mine's a couple years old, but worked fine.  Probably all the lubricant coalesced into one place due to lack of use, though.  So will follow this thread to see what people recommend.

[grawk]

Wouldn't mind knowing what you're ripping DVDs with, I have some DVDs I'd like to get the audio off of (Riina Shingo...er...Ringo Sheena, some live concert DVDs, the Advanced Electronics series, etc.).
Mine's a couple years old, but worked fine.  Probably all the lubricant coalesced into one place due to lack of use, though.  So will follow this thread to see what people recommend.

I use handbrake for dvds and makemkv for Blu-ray

[TMoney]

Another vote here for makemkv. I've used it for years to rip my dvds and blurays to a plex server.

[sbelyo]

I use makemkv for DVD's so far.  Haven't ripped Blurays yet.  For DVD-A I've been using DVD Audio extractor I think.  For CD's Foobar200 lately, previously EAC

[Dusty Chalk]

Ah, I had been previously using anyDVD HD, but then they switched to RedFox and I didn’t feel comfortable paying for it again.  Yet another reason to buy a Mac.

[HiWire]

Blu-ray playback on the Mac is a pain in the ass... I looked into it a while ago and decided to do Blu-ray stuff only on my Windows computer.

I've used Pioneer drives in my desktop computers since Plextor stopped making their own. This seems to be the latest one:

https://www.pioneerelectronics.com/PUSA/Computer/Computer+Drives/BDR-211UBK

Theoretically, it supports Ultra HD Blu-ray, but online reviews indicate a weird situation with HDCP 2.2 support and Intel SGX – you might need Intel's Kaby Lake for it to work. I think regular Blu-ray playback should be fine with something like PowerDVD. I wish VLC could add Blu-ray support... content protection is still a giant ball of fail for the consumer. The good news is that there is no region coding on Ultra HD Blu-rays.

[grawk]

makemkv works fine on mac.   I've had bluray playback software on my mac for years as well.

[Dusty Chalk]

19 hours ago, sbelyo said:

For DVD-A I've been using DVD Audio extractor I think. 

Hey, do you think that’d work for audio from regular DVD-Vs?  That might be all I need.

[sbelyo]

I seem to remember something like it could.  I do also remember something about ripping the audio from DVDs in another program as well.  If I have time tonight I'll poke around on the machine to see what work.  IFO edit comes to mind or at the very least tells you what the audio tracks are like 2ch stereo with whatever processing like dolby etc.

[sbelyo]

On 11/29/2017 at 4:48 PM, Dusty Chalk said:

Hey, do you think that’d work for audio from regular DVD-Vs?  That might be all I need.

It looks like DVD audio extracter will, but I did not have it installed.  I was using DVD Audio Explorer.  That program will not unfortunately