Both, with an emphasis on the latter. I don't think he is a great reviewer but I also don't appreciate noobs with no reputation or credibility coming in and calling Guttenberg a retard.
Agreed.
Nobody here on this site would make the leap you fear, so don't feel the need to protect us from ourselves.
The reason I would bother here at all is because Guttenberg is also Tyll's click whore, so clearly I'm being more protective than otherwise.