Jeff,
If you like specialized shoes and are ok running spd pedals you might look at the higher-end mtb shoes which often use the same uppers as the road shoes but just have the modified sole to allow for running/walking on the trail. I run a pretty basic pair of specialized mtb shoes that are super comfy, very well ventilated and also very easy to walk in. The S-Works EVO or S-Works MTB shoes would fit the shiney requirement, work with your existing pedals and not rape your floors.
[edit]I'll probably try to move up to something like the Pro MTB shoe this year. Two years on my shoes is probably enough stink to warrant a new pair. Hmmm, sounds like a good birthday idea...