Yes, I knew there were faults in the logic, but my point was that I don't intimately know the timbre of any other instrument.
The one instrument I do know the timbre of, vinyl reproduces most accurately.
In fact, one of redbook's biggest drawbacks is that resolution decreases dramatically at high frequency. By design, redbook can produce no higher than 22 khz, and at that frequency, no more than a square wave.
Redbook misses out on high frequencies that, although inaudible, influence the harmonics of the audible range of an instrument.
I listen, and enjoy CDs for their convenience. Vinyl, though, is superior.
Call me Grandpa.
Keep listening to your MP3's through a soundcard.
It keeps the price of second hand vinyl low.