Hmm. I've avoided buying or even hearing this because I liked Underdow and I really liked AEnima and was utterly disappointed with Lateralus. When I buy a metal album, I want it to rock, not be a ponderous pseudo-tribute to bands like Yes (who I also happen to like, sometimes).
So, what is this new one? Is it more of the ponderous, nearly hook-less exploration of Lateralus, or the tighter more hook-driven metal of Undertow or AEnima? There seems to be an inconsistency of opinion on this...