I think we should state what we can play: SACD, DVD Audio, CD, or vinyl. That way "Santa" knows what to get without worries. Also, why not extend this to t-shirts as well? I see a lot of people here buying music-related t-shirts, and it would be a nice option as well.
Btw, that head-fi thread is missing one crucial thing: does this remain anonymous, or will people be paired off? I believe that we should keep this a secret santa sorta thing. In order for this to work, there has to be one person choreographing (at random, preferably) who gets who. Each person receives an email stating the name and address of their recipient. That way, you don't know who's sending you something.
Just a thought!
Anyhow, Screaming Oranges: CD, SACD, Vinyl. T-shirt size: Medium.
I'm in like a virgin.
Wait, wut.
EDIT: ASR, just noticed your sig quote.